A recent crisis arose at Baylor University between the Administration and the Baylor Alumni Association. Apparently Baylor University Administration is seeking to shut down all dissent by
swallowing the independent Baylor Alumni Association whole.
This unprecedented maneuver to squelch free and open discussion offers few warm fuzzies to Baylor students/alumni (//link).
Rightly so.
Moderate Baptist faith communities proudly pave their streets with enriched diversity and seal them with open dissent.
As a counter-measure, a Baylor dissenter posted on a forum thread an older essay by Dr. Malcolm Yarnell entitled "Unauthorized Consent: Self-perpetuating Trustee Boards Violate Historic Baptist Principles" (2002), originally appearing in the Missouri Baptist state paper, The Pathway (//link; //link).
At the time, Dr. Yarnell was dean of faculty and associate professor of historical theology at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Presently, he serves as Associate Professor of Systematic Theology at the Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. In addition, he also is Director of the Oxford
Study Program, Director of the Center for Theological Research, and
Editor of the Southwestern Journal of Theology (//link).
Below is the essay in full.*
Even though the contextual matters Dr. Yarnell addressed in 2002 concerned self-perpetuating trustee boards and their deviance from Baptist principle, the overall thrust of the essay speaks superbly to possible illicit power-moves at times unfortunately indicative of appointed boards or committees of the SBC (thankfully not often).
For example, only recently, we heard counsel issued from the GCRTF to the presidential search committees to look to the GCRTF for guidance as the presidential committees look for God's agent to head our entities, even though the GCRTF clearly possesses no authoritative commission to guide the SBC, much less guide the presidential search (//link).
The GCRTF is a study committee not a structural committee. It may report; it cannot revise. The GCRTF may inform; it cannot implement.
Given that, Dr. Yarnell's essay stands as a much needed corrective to any SBC board or committee to carefully avoid the appearance of assuming authority never given.
With that, I am...
Peter
*Dr. Yarnell's important essay, "Unauthorized Consent: Self-perpetuating Trustee Boards Violate Historic Baptist Principles" is published below by written permission